Forums › Forums › Fungi ID requests (post here if you aren’t sure what type of fungus you’ve found) › Fungi ID please
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
October 23, 2015 at 10:47 am #29881
I have been trying to ID these is first one Lactarius subdulcis or an Inocybe? both look similar in my fungi book. Growing under beech, peat/rock, no particular smell and no droplets or darkening when cap broken in half. Think the second one is Lycoperdon perlatum, these are appearing around the fungi in 1st photo, so same location growing conditions. [attachment=1]20151023_11.JPG[/attachment] [attachment=0]20151023_8.JPG[/attachment] I know in the past you have given me ID for 1st photo, but I must have taken grotty photos as I can’t make out difference
🙄 October 23, 2015 at 11:14 am #36909Generally a milkcap will exude milk when broken, and they are usually fairly brittle. I bet your first one had a rubbery cap, and tough stem. It might be Pholiota alnicola, but that is only a guess based on what I can see. The pinkish brown gills and dark stem base do suggest something along those lines. But I would not be surprised if I was wrong. What you really need to do is to photograph the cap and gills, which you have done, but also the stem. Try and note down the texture and smell too. Rubbery flesh is of course quite distinct from brittle or hard flesh. And some smells are quite strong. I agree with your second one.
I had a concern this was another Otidea post.
😆 October 23, 2015 at 1:02 pm #36910They may look similar in the book but Lactarius has white spores and Inocybes brown spores (and a fibrous cap). I think the first image may be our old and variable friend, the Honey Fungus (Armillaria sp.).
October 23, 2015 at 3:29 pm #36911October 23, 2015 at 3:47 pm #36912Please provide bigger photos or in this case close-ups of the stem. To me, it looks like a Tricholoma, but could be Honey Fungus too. There are some guides on posting images here.
http://fungi.org.uk/viewforum.php?f=2http://fungi.org.uk/viewforum.php?f=2” class=”bbcode_url”> October 23, 2015 at 4:05 pm #36913It’s a shame the first one didn’t seem to have a distinctive smell. It looks like Hebeloma radicosum to me. If you had noted the rooting stem this would also have helped to confirm the identification. Often H. radicosum doesn’t have much of a smell, even though the books says it does. Ken
October 23, 2015 at 4:21 pm #36914There isn’t really enough information in the photos to see the relevant characters. In case it helps to see if it fits, here is the description of Hebeloma radicosum from Fungi of Northern Europe 3. ‘Medium sized to large with a conspicuously rooting stem and a strongly developed universal veil forming a membranous ring and mostly with a smell like marzipan.
DESCRIPTION: Cap 25-110 mm, hemispherical, then expanded, with or without a low, broad umbo, margin decurved, with a thick slime-layer, often with appressed, sordid whitish to brownish grey scales, not hygrophanous, pale cream to cream or warm buff, towards the centre sometimes dark pinkish buff to ochraceous, sometimes with claybuff to umber spots. Gills emarginate, broad, crowded, dark greyish buff to clay-buff, edge concolorous or slightly paler, but not distinctly whitish-fimbriate, without droplets. Stem 35-120 x 8-15 mm, cylindrical or widened in the basal part, with a distinct, spindle-shaped, rooting base, with a membranous ring, above the ring pruinose to flocculose, under the ring floccose, at first whitish to pale cream, gradually turning claybuff to greyish brown or umber from the base. Flesh solid or partly hollow or stuffed in the stem, white or whitish, in the outer part of the stem discolouring through clay-buff to greyish brown from the base. Cortina absent; universal veil very strongly developed (forming the membraneous ring and cap scales). Smell distinct to strong, marzipan-like, occasionally almost inodorous in young specimens. Taste mild to bitter.
ECOLOGY AND DISTRIBUTION: In deciduous forests on rich or fairly rich soil, especially under Fagus, but also with Carpinus, Quercus and probably Tilia, Betula and Corylus. It is favoured by the presence of nitrogen compounds, like for instance in vole nests.’
Ken
October 23, 2015 at 4:33 pm #36915PS The caps look like they were sticky before drying out as they have debris adhering to them. October 23, 2015 at 5:04 pm #36916Hello Nelly, no I am not Leifus. I am UK based. Can you get a closer photo? To be honest Roy and Ken could well be correct! October 23, 2015 at 5:45 pm #36917It could be Hebeloma radicosum; but all fungus identification starts with SPORE COLOUR – even before you look at images. A simple spore print would clearly indicate if it could be a Hebeloma (dull brown spores) or not, or Honey Fungus (white spores) or indeed Pholiota (rusty brown spores).
October 23, 2015 at 6:32 pm #36918… and it would avoid a lot of discussion up blind alleys if we had spore colour up front, as I know to my cost only too well. 
Ken
October 23, 2015 at 7:08 pm #36919We only have three suggestions, there’s room for more. October 24, 2015 at 12:51 pm #36920Gosh you guys are wonderful. I will go out and get one and do a spore sample and gather other info, and check with the info given – I hope! We had torrential rain yesterday and frost overnight (got our 1st snow on the hills) and it is still raining. I know I could tog up
October 24, 2015 at 4:46 pm #36921Looking now on a laptop screen rather than my phone, I think the characters don’t fit well with my earlier suggestion of H. radicosum. 🙄 As Leif suggests, the lack of clear characters leaves things wide open e.g. the browning of the lower part of the stem and maybe a hint of banding could even suggest Cortinarius trivialis (but that’s just another wild stab in the dark ). Probably best to let this one go unless by some fluke they haven’t all disintegrated.
Ken
October 25, 2015 at 1:50 pm #36922Hope better photo. So cap almost slimy even when dried off a bit. Smell – earthy, no particular taste. I found it impossible to get one up with its full base – even using a knife, just kept breaking off at base, it is on extremely stony ground with fine layer of moss and leaf debris, think if it had roots they were caught up in the rocky ground. The spores are dark brown. The biggest cap is 7cm, though might be bigger only the edges of the cap had curled upwards and as I only had a stiff ruler could not follow contour. there were no droplets of milk when cut or broken. [attachment=1]20151025_9.JPG[/attachment] [attachment=0]20151025_4.JPG[/attachment] -
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
