Hi
Not getting notifications of new threads, so missed this, but the simple answer is it not either Cladonia cervicornis or Cladonia verticillata. This is because it has a granular cortex; the Stacking Cups have a smooth cortex without granules or soralia and cups with a shallow flat base, see link & link.
This is definitely something in the Cladonia chlorophaea s. lat. group link (proliferating podetia not uncommon in this group), but given the look (not green enough for typical Cladonia chlorophaea s. str.) and habitat (very acid) most likely one of Cladonia grayi group of species. Further spot test might get us closer, but probably unlikely to be definitive but look for UV fluorescence (bright blue-mauve would be Cladonia grayi s. str.) and test for any KC reaction (+ strong but fleeting wine red would be Cladonia cryptochlorophaea or Cladonia merochlorophaea).
Neil