Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I agree with everything Roy says above and my comments come with that caveat. Sometimes there are shortcuts that can help with Russula species, but you usually need to follow preliminary thoughts up with a full description, including microscopy, to reach a firm ID.
With this specimen we have clues in the deep yellow ochre gills and the distinctive yellowing of the stem. For me, this would bring to mind Russula puellaris, which grows with broadleaves and conifers. However, there is also a look-alike known as R. versicolor which grows with Betula, a species I have not knowingly found myself. With the cap colours in the photo and overall appearance I would start looking in this area but it would need a lot more work to take it any further.
Ken
Hi Adam I have both books and I usually end up using both of them. There are advantages and disadvantages to both. And often I find myself digging into the Fungi Europaei volume as well.
The FNE book is much more comprehensive in terms of its species coverage and descriptive information. But it includes a lot of species that may not occur in the UK.
Geoffrey Kibby’s book clearly states which species are not yet known in Britain and you may get to an answer more quickly than with FNE, but sometimes there just isn’t quite enough detail to be certain of an identification (particularly for species which are new to you) and a second source with more detail can help.
FNE also includes the author’s thoughts on the identification of specimens in earlier publications covering Tricholoma (highlighting some of the challenges with this genera). It includes comments on Geoffrey Kibby’s book in respect of 5 of his illustrations on which they take a different view.
I couldn’t recommend one over the other because I find both are very useful.
Ken
Hi Steve These small whitish Clitocybe species are terribly difficult. You need to get a decent spore print to check the colour and then you need to measure a lot of spores to get accurate measurements and a Q value.
Both C. truncicola and C. candicans also have the pruina on the cap surface and white spore deposits (rather than the pinkish cream spore print of C. phyllophila). The spores of C. truncicola are supposed to be both shorter and broader than C. candicans.
From FAN3:
C. truncicola: Spores 4.5-5.5(-6.0) x 3.5-4.0(-4.5) um, Q = 1.2-1.4(-1.5), Q = 1.3,
C. candicans: Spores (4.5-)5.0-6.5(-7.0) x 2.5-3.5(-4.0) um, Q = 1.5-1.8(-1.9), Q = 1.5-1.8
You should be able to separate them on this basis. Having said that, I found something similar growing on a very decomposed log but the spores had a Q value that was too high to fit with C. truncicola. I called it C. candicans, but without a lot of conviction!
Ken
Have you seen this key to Helvella in Europe? http://www.ascomycete.org/Portals/0/PDF/Dissing001.pdfhttp://www.ascomycete.org/Portals/0/PDF/Dissing001.pdf” class=”bbcode_url”> Ken
If the gills are more closely spaced and the bruising is red through brown to black, as in Dave’s finds, it is always worth having a nibble of the gills to check if they are very acrid. If so, this would point to Russula acrifolia, rather than Russula densifolia (in which the flesh and gills would be mild to only very slightly acrid). I think R. acrifolia only grows with broadleaves though.
Ken
I haven’t got any books with me as I am babysitting my grandchildren, but they have the look of Tubaria conspersa, although I have never seen this species with such a prominent umbo. May be somewhere to start looking? Ken
Thick, widely spaced gills and flushing red through brown to black on bruising, this is typical Russula nigricans. Ken
The image at the attached link would be my impression of the typical colour of N. subconspersa. http://www.stridvall.se/fungi/gallery/Naucoria/SV07_075http://www.stridvall.se/fungi/gallery/Naucoria/SV07_075” class=”bbcode_url”> Ken
I usually leave my Naucoria finds until last, by which time they have usually disintegrated and can be thrown in the compost bin. 
Have you seen the key by Alick Henrici?
http://www.britmycolsoc.org.uk/files/1013/3094/7680/Naucoria%20in%20Britain%20by%20Alick%20Henrici.pdf ” class=”bbcode_url”> http://www.britmycolsoc.org.uk/files/1013/3094/7680/Naucoria%20in%20Britain%20by%20Alick%20Henrici.pdf This highlights the problems in trying to identify Naucoria to species level. I’m not sure where you would find good quality images of properly identified specimens, which makes visual confirmation after keying out a problem.
Your specimens don’t look particularly reddish-brown in colour to me but image colour isn’t always faithfully reproduced on the screen. Did you rule out Naucoria escharioides, which is the commonest yellow-brown species?
Ken
Small Cortinarius species in the Telamonia group are a nightmare. Unless you can find something distinctive, such as a strong smell, you are unlikely to get very far. And you need specimens at different stages of development to make any progress. You refer to a red veil. But is the partial veil actually red, or could it be, for example, white but stained rusty brown from the spores trapped in the veil? Unless you have an immature specimen that has not dropped any spores, you’d be hard pressed to tell and without that information you would fall at the first hurdle.
According to Geoffrey Kibby, the majority of Telamonia species in the UK have not been properly described so even the experts strugle.
🙄 Ken
I agree with Mal. I think this is Russula raoultii. When I saw the shot of the gills they reminded me very much of Russula betularum or Russula fragilis, but obviously the cap colour is wrong. Interestingly, Geoff Kibby says of R. raoultii: ‘a small pretty species like a yellowish, washed out R. fragilis’.
If you get some guaiac, the reaction for Russula raoultii is supposed to be ‘rapid and intense blue’.
Ideally, to confirm it you would need to look at the spores in Melzers to see the ornamentation more clearly and get accurate measurements from a large number of spores. Your spore measurements look somewhat too large for R. raoultii. I’d check your calibration but I would also point out that you should only measure spores that are fully in view in that they are flat to the viewing plane. If you look at the spore labelled with measurements 8.05 x 7.35 this is being measured almost end on. As it is not flat to the viewing plane, your measurements will therefore be inaccurate if you include spores in this orientation.
Also, if you are going to look at Russula finds in more depth your really need to get a feel for the different smells. According to Geoff Kibby R. raoultii smells ‘pleasant, slightly fruity’. So it should have some smell. You mention a number of species which, with an experienced eye, could have been ruled out quickly by their jizz. But even with an inexperienced eye, they could have been ruled out by smell alone. Russula fellea, Russula grata, Russula illota and Russula farinipes all have strong and distinctive smells, whereas your specimen must have a weak smell at most.
For future reference, I would make a note of all nearby tree species e.g. you should not rule out birch-related species simply because the nearest birch is some distance away. The mycorrhizal network could spread a long way from a particular tree, or you may have overlooked another birch among the oaks.
Ken
It has the right colouration and growth form for Omphalotus illudens, which is the US species according to mushroomexpert.com. However, to be certain you would need a view of the gills and stem, and preferably a spore print to confirm the colour of the spores.
Ken
Looks spot on to me. Ken
September 5, 2015 at 12:24 pm in reply to: Tricky little white job (powdery and smell of ink) #36134Cystolepiota bucknallii has a strong smell of coal tar but tends to have violaceous tones rather than pink. Edit: just seen your edit and the new image!
Ken
There are not many options for Lactarius when you have a cap as dark as this, which helps considerably. If the milk is white (watery) and unchanging that narrows it down even further.
For me, your specimen has all the characters of Lactarius subumbonatus (with a very dark brown cap), but this is now synonymised by many authors with Lactarius serifluus, encompassing a range of cap colours varying from reddish brown to dark brown. The crenulate cap margin visible in your photos is also characteristic.
The smell is usually distinctive – a bit like Lactarius quietus but also described as sweetish.
Ken
-
AuthorPosts