Verrucaria elaeina?

Forums › Forums › Lichens › Verrucaria elaeina?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #32001
    John Norton
    Participant

      Would anyone agree that the pics below show Verrucaria elaeina? I can’t find anything else that fits and it does more or less fit with the description in LGBI and the habitat. Spore length averages around 18-20 microns. The specimens were from large boulders of a shale of some sort, part of the artificial sea defence on the Gosport side of the mouth of Portsmouth Harbour. It was growing with V. nigrescens, V. muralis, Lecania atrynoides and Aspicilia sp., but not much Caloplaca, so not too strongly calcareous. It was on loose fragments laying on the surface, so quite exposed, but the site is fairly humid (plenty of mosses) and would occasionally be subject to salt spray. The perithecia are almost fully immsersed in the thallus (and slightly so in the substrate), at least at first, but become a bit more exposed when older; up to 0.4mm diameter. The thallus is rimose (or areolate?) and distinctly heaped up around the perithecia. I can’t find any photos on the internet that show V. elaeina as 3D as this. I had trouble cutting sections and couldn’t isolate the involucrellum (up to now I’ve done very little microscope work on crustose lichens). If present, it must merge into the exciple, which is black all round. The ostiole is virtually invisible. Any ideas?

      M69865 Verrucaria elaeina Gosport Ferry rocks.jpg

      [attachment=5]M69865 Verrucaria elaeina Gosport Ferry rocks.jpg[/attachment]

      M69872 Verrucaria elaeina Gosport Ferry rocks.jpg

      [attachment=4]M69872 Verrucaria elaeina Gosport Ferry rocks.jpg[/attachment]

      Verrucaria elaeina Gosport Ferry rocks_07.jpg

      [attachment=3]Verrucaria elaeina Gosport Ferry rocks_07.jpg[/attachment]

      M69853 Verrucaria elaeina Gosport Ferry rocks.jpg

      [attachment=2]M69853 Verrucaria elaeina Gosport Ferry rocks.jpg[/attachment]

      Verrucaria elaeina ostiolar region Ferry 23jan2021-0004.jpg

      [attachment=1]Verrucaria elaeina ostiolar region Ferry 23jan2021-0004.jpg[/attachment]

      #43930
      Mark Powell
      Participant

        I will have a go at saying something about this Verrucaria, having spent many, many hours struggling with this genus, sometimes with great success (having added several species to the British list, some of them common) but with a great deal of time spent working on specimens without satisfactory resolutions.

        First let me give my overall impression of the appearance of this lichen. It just doesn’t look right for V. elaeina. The thallus looks too thick and matt, too much inclined to split into lumpy areoles, rather than the flatter thallus with almost a silky or greasy sheen of V. elaeina.

        This is fairly classic V. elaeina:

        elaein.jpeg

        [attachment=3]elaein.jpeg[/attachment]

        I think your lichen looks like rather suppressed V. viridula. Here is an image of well developed V. viridula:

        viridul1.jpeg

        [attachment=2]viridul1.jpeg[/attachment]
        Perhaps you can imagine how a stunted version of this, lacking the distinct brown tinge of this sun-exposed specimen, could look very much like your material?

        The appearance of the thallus, the way the small protruding apices of the perithecia conceal just how voluminous the body of the perithecia are, and the way that the base of the perithecia are embedded in the substratum are all reminiscent of V. viridula. Where we can see a cut face of some perithecia there is a fairly good indication of an ‘elongated ostiolar region’ resulting in a slight neck.

        viridu2.jpeg

        [attachment=1]viridu2.jpeg[/attachment]

        viridu3.png

        [attachment=0]viridu3.png[/attachment]

        The only thing that would be disconcerting for many lichenologists is that the ascospores appear to be very small for V. viridula. I have come across this issue quite a few times in the past, specimens which are clearly V. viridula in my opinion but with many of the ascospores at or a bit below the bottom of the stated range in the Flora. Also note that the ascospores you have measured, perhaps the only ones available to you, are still in a bundle of eight, perhaps still in their ascus and may not be fully developed. I have long meant to perform a study on the true sizes of ascospores in V. ochrostoma and in V. viridula to determine whether well-developed material produces ascospores with a larger range of size than stunted material. I am very wary of lichenologists who place too much weight on spore size, while ignoring many other important features of thallus and perithecial structure.

        I wonder if you have access to any known V. viridula John? I made useful progress in my studies by direct comparisons between ‘good’ specimens of a Verrucaria species and potential stunted versions of the same. Let me know if I can help with this further. For the moment I have a strong suspicion that you have rather stunted V. viridula but can’t confirm this as a definite record.

        #43931
        John Norton
        Participant

          Hi Mark

          Thanks very much for your useful comments. I’m certainly inclined to agree with you about it being V. viridula. As it happens I had recently looked at what I believe is that species on the brick wall where I found Vezdaea leprosa (see pics below). That material by contrast had only a poorly developed thallus and almost fully exposed perithecia, making them look quite large, but I think the perithecia were similarly about 0.4mm across. They had a distinct ostiole and the elongated ostiolar region which you describe (which LGBI calls a ‘projection’) and there is certainly a similarity to my mystery specimen. The spores were also of the ‘correct’ size. Although I looked at at several perithecia on the mystery specimen and they all had small spores, I think you may be right that they were mostly immature, but maybe the different substrate and conditions, including a slight saline influence, could have had an effect? I’m hoping I’ll have time to look at more coastal crustose lichens around here – they have been neglected in the past and I think there could be some interesting species waiting to be found.

          M69518 Verrucaria viridula.jpg

          [attachment=1]M69518 Verrucaria viridula.jpg[/attachment]

          Verrucaria viridula Forton 27dec2020-0002(2).jpg

          [attachment=0]Verrucaria viridula Forton 27dec2020-0002(2).jpg[/attachment]

        Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
        • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
        Scroll to Top