Forums › Forums › Fungi ID requests (post here if you aren’t sure what type of fungus you’ve found) › sand dune fungi
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
November 24, 2020 at 4:46 pm #31931
Hello, Been on this one for 2 hours and not getting anywhere, hoping someone might know the genus or species? Keying out to various eg Clitocybe, Tricholoma, Melanoleuca and Mycena. In sand dunes in Somerset. Cap 36mm across light tomentose, stipe 30×4.5mm heavily tomentose.
Thanks, Paul
November 25, 2020 at 12:29 am #43711Hi Paul sorry you have spent (wasted) 2 hours on this. How did you spend that time – I hope not looking at pictures on the web . . . ? It’s not a
Mycena(too robust); Melanoleucawould need microscopy; microscopy doesn’t usually help with Clitocybe– it’s a genus which requires a range of fruitbodies, and (it often seems to me) the ability to decide whether the gills are “pale greyish-brown” or “pale brownish-grey”; it looks wrong for Tricholoma– hard to say why based on what I can see – just based on years of experience. I would recommend following advice I was given when I started out on this difficult study – “one fruitbody is not a fungus” – you need several, at different stages. If it’s any consolation, based on this solitary fruitbody I would definitely have followed Dionne Warwick’s advice and just “Walked on By”.
Chris
November 25, 2020 at 12:29 am #43712Hi Paul sorry you have spent (wasted) 2 hours on this. How did you spend that time – I hope not looking at pictures on the web . . . ? It’s not a
Mycena(too robust); Melanoleuca( perhaps-marginally – the best guess) would need microscopy; microscopy doesn’t usually help with Clitocybe– it’s a genus which requires a range of fruitbodies, and (it often seems to me) the ability to decide whether the gills are “pale greyish-brown” or “pale brownish-grey”; it looks wrong for Tricholoma– hard to say why based on what I can see – just based on years of experience. I would recommend following advice I was given when I started out on this difficult study – “one fruitbody is not a fungus” – you need several, at different stages. If it’s any consolation, based on this solitary fruitbody I would definitely have followed Dionne Warwick’s advice and just “Walked on By”.
Chris
November 25, 2020 at 8:38 am #43713Chris is mostly right, although I wouldn’t say time spent in mycology is wasted, as we learn as much from mistakes or failures as we do from successes. If I was determined enough, I’d start with a full microscopic examination and attempt to key it out using Funga Nordica. A big part of this depends on the pileipellis (cap skin) structure. I would expect Clitocybe to have decurrent gills though.
It might help to see the base, whether it was growing on buried wood, soil of plant stems and a clear view of the gill attachment. Did you consider the lepiotoids?
November 25, 2020 at 8:56 am #43714Hi Chris/Adam, Thanks for your reply. I was keying out with the key to genus in Funga Nordica but some options I wasn’t sure about so keying multiple ways hence the numerous different options eg the pileipellis I think is cutis although lack of experience means I could be mistaken. As for the substrate, the base is a mass of white cobweb like filaments growing amongst Syntrichia ruraliformis. I thought it looked distinctive enough to attempt so with fresh eyes I’ll have another go today and post back if I get definitive answer. Best Wishes, Paul November 25, 2020 at 11:34 am #43715Having worked through it again more thoroughly I am now leaning towards a brown form of Lepista sordida (there are purple toned Lepista sordida nearby). The gill type looks like emarginate to me. The spores give no reaction to meltzers and at 1,000 they could possibly be minutely verrucose. If smooth the key takes me to Tricholoma. November 25, 2020 at 4:29 pm #43716You can rule out Tricholoma unless there are trees nearby, November 25, 2020 at 5:39 pm #43717Of course the irony is that there are probably at least three identifiable fungi on those dead grass stems . . . November 25, 2020 at 5:49 pm #43718Thanks Adam, I can’t remember will have to check. Only Sea Buckthorn in the dunes but there are trees on the edge of the dunes but unsure of the distance. Might just run it through the Tricholoma keys just in case… November 25, 2020 at 9:12 pm #43719PaulBowyer wrote:
. . . OnlySea Buckthornin the dunes . . .
Keep an eye open forFomitiporia( Phellinus) hippophaeicola; there is a least one previous Somerset record – Berrow Dunes. Cheers
Chris
PSI’ve just read a bit about Berrow Dunes, and seen some images – looks like mycological heaven – dune systems is one habitat we are not well blessed with here in Yorkshire, sadly . . . November 26, 2020 at 6:46 pm #43720Thanks Chris, will take a look at Berrow and see how it compares. Best Wishes, Paul November 27, 2020 at 9:24 am #43721Pembrokeshire fungi recording group published a good little book on Dune Fungi but I don’t know if they have any left. https://www.pembsfungi.org.uk/ and there’s a French book “Le petit livre des Champignons des dunes” by Jacques Guinbertau
https://www.amazon.co.uk/petit-livre-champignons-dunes/dp/2355270635 Hope that helps
February 5, 2021 at 11:38 pm #43722Having looked at a lot of dune fungi over the last few years, I am trying to think what I would think this was if I walked past it – and whether I would stop and take a closer look. Somehow not so easy with a photograph… I’ve decided I would think it’s
Clitocybe agrestis. Very common on dunes, but under-recorded. More or less white, but variable with age and weather. Thin-fleshed. Not very decurrent lamellae. Almost completely featureless microscopically. Stipe smooth but initially may have some cobwebby mycelium. Best guess. If it’s not that, I ‘ve no idea. Tricholomaspecies (which this is not) can occur in dune slacks with Salix repenscreeping willow which, from the point of view of an ectomycorrhizal fungus, is just as good as a tree-sized non-creeping willow. I recall seeing the
Fomitopsison sea buckthorn at the pitiful remnant of dune at Minehead – a thin strip squeezed between Butlins and the beach, but still harbouring some marram grass and a few associated fungi. Keep searching the dunes! Interesting place for interesting species.
February 6, 2021 at 4:58 pm #43723Thanks Peter. A while ago now since I recorded in Sand Bay but seem to remember finding a small population that appeared to be C.agrestis so I think a good suggestion. I agree that dunes appear remarkably good for fungi so am thinking about trying to get the local fungi group down there in the autumn. Cheers, Paul -
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.