- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
March 4, 2021 at 11:16 pm #32051
I don’t come across Parmelinas that often, and I’ve only ever seen what I believe to be Parmelina pastillifera in Gloucestershire. This specimen was from a horizontal branch of an old Ash tree on a field boundary amid arable. I am pretty confident that it is pastillifera, rather than tiliacea – which has been recorded in Gloucestershire, but not by me. However, the isidia only briefly go through the “bun” stage as described in Dobson, and quickly turn into a contorted knobbly mess. Dobson is further confusing, or at least ambiguous, in that couplet 13 on p315 of the key says “thallus without pseudocyphellae or cilia” which I read as meaning it doesnt have either of these features until going on to the Parmelina introduction on p321 where cilia are admitted. A feature mentioned on the AFL website, but not in Dobson or the Flora, is that the isidia leave scars when they drop off, but this doesn’t happen with tiliaceae. I definitely have neat little scars here but I haven’t got comparative material of tiliacea to examine.
Juliet
March 5, 2021 at 12:14 pm #44055Frustratingly I can’t lay my hands on a specimen of P. tiliaceaat the moment so I can’t provide the directly observed comments that I would wish. However, I am very pleased that you have raised this issue, the separation of P. tiliaceaand P. pastillifera, which sounds so straightforward in the books but I know has caused problems in the past. I am also very grateful for the tip-off about the AFL website which I agree provides better guidance than the British literature or sites. I think the usual separation, concentrating on the form and colour of the isidia, works fairly well with well-developed specimens. The problems sometimes arise when juvenile specimens or small fragments of material are examined. For reasons of conservation-minded frugality, some people have collected a couple of outer lobes and then struggled to interpret the immature isidia present. It would be really great if we could produce a well-illustrated guide to interpreting the isidia in this pair, building on the already good hints provided by the AFL website. When we look online or in books for illustrations of this pair, we get numerous overviews of whole thalli but very few informative close-ups of the isidia and their development. -
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.