On Tilia sp. Help

Forums › Forums › Lichens › On Tilia sp. Help

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #32310

    Good afternoon, I saw these large lichenes on tree (Tilia sp). They were very big, 4-6 inches diameter. They were gray-blue, in city next to a busy road.

    Thanks everybody

    #44668
    Mark Powell
    Participant

      I can’t make out enough detail in the first three images. They may show the same lichen as the final two but as I can’t be sure, and to make clear, my comments relate only to your last two photos. They are a species of Punctelia and my reasons for saying so is that they have the general appearance of a grey ‘parmelioid’ and the soralia develop from white spots visible on the marginal lobes. There are four species of Punctelia in Britain, but P. jeckeri has a rather different appearance to your lichen and P. reddenda is almost certainly ruled out by the habitat/situation. That leaves the look-alike pair P. borreri and P. subrudecta. To make a certain decision between these two I would need a really good crisp close up of the lobe surface to check for the presence of pruina (which would indicate P. borreri) or absence of pruina in P. subrudecta. I would also need to know how dark the undersurface is. The books say that P. borreri is black underneath and P. subrudecta is pale underneath but it is not actually that simple. One needs to observe the transition of darkness from margin to central parts and check that it really does go darker and darker and become jet black in central parts to confirm P. borreri.

      Some time ago, I produced a twitter thread providing quite a bit of detail about distinguishing the British Punctelia species in case it is of interest:

      https://twitter.com/obfuscans3/status/1210862789666988034

      I think there is a good chance that your lichen is P. borreri based on a gut feeling of its general appearance but that is not good enough evidence to record it as such. I would need to know about the features mentioned above to be sure.

      #44669

      First, thank you so much for your answers!

      I tried to split lichen from wood for looking underneath. I tried to clean from wood, it was hard.

      It seems brown. I can’ t see pruina on surface.

      Please, look photos.

      Could you say specie of Punctelia?

      Thanks!

      Francesco

      #44670

      ..

      #44671
      Mark Powell
      Participant

        I’m really sorry, and I don’t want to be unhelpful or dismissive, but I am struggling to keep track of which individual thallus we are trying to identify. This is an important matter since several grey foliose species may grow together in a community and if we are to reliably identify them, we need to analyse their features individually. That is why I tried to specify which images I was commenting on in my first reply (I was unsure how many individuals were presented to us). In the last photo that you have posted there seems to be a network of white ridges connecting the white spots. The distinction between Parmelia and Punctelia can be really tricky because of the former mimicking the punctiform soralia of the latter.

        I really want to help but I think we need detailed images and information about a single, well-developed thallus at a time.

        In the meantime, here are some grey ‘parmelioids’

        https://twitter.com/obfuscans3/status/1487879443846680579

        and some more:

        https://twitter.com/obfuscans3/status/1488622606437785601

        Best wishes,

        Mark

        #44672

        Thak you so much, Mark! I took lichens from different trees so, maybe, they are similar but different species. I’ m sorry, Mark. Next time I’ ll take one only thallus. Thanks

        Francesco

      Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
      • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
      Scroll to Top