Both species you mention should have a distinct sac-like volva at the base of the stem.
It is essential when removing examples for ID purposes, that the entirety of the fruitbody (right down to the stem base) is collected.
In many instances, what can be found/seen or not found/seen at the stem base may be critical to correct species identification.
For what it’s worth, of the two species you name, I’d be leaning towards Volvopluteus gloiocephalus.
(On the basis that I would expect to be seeing a generally darker colour, and striations towards the margins of the caps of Amanita Vaginata examples of that sort of size).
Regards,
Mike.