Forums › Forums › Fungi ID requests (post here if you aren’t sure what type of fungus you’ve found) › Hohenbuehelia cyphelliformis – I think
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
May 23, 2015 at 10:22 pm #29382
Hohenbuehelia cyphelliformis As we were having a brief sit down by a huge pile of millstones in Longshaw, Les simply picked up a birch? twig and said “This one’s got gills”. The tiny oysterling attached to it looked like a grey immature Crepidotus cesatii – plenty of which we find on the Estate. However, there were very few gills, and no spores were deposited. I waited a couple of days to let it grow on – but then decided to do the microscopy before the bugs ruined it. The numerous metuloid cystidia, up to 70 um long, pointed to Hohenbuehelia – which I’d never found before. I did find a single spore – oblong (slightly allantoid?), 10 x 4.5, In addition to the metuloids which were on the gill edge and embedded within the tissue, were other peculiar “gloeosphex cheilocystidia, mostly single headed but also two-headed – looking like oddly shaped basidia. Basidia were in fact very difficult to spot. Clamps were easy to find. The cap cuticle was resting on a 0.2mm layer of gloopy brown gel. A squash of the cap cuticle showed pigment-encrusted hyphal tissue. I wasn’t over- convinced by any descriptions in Funga Nordica or Buckzacki (FOS has little on this genus), but Alex Henrici’s key in Field Mycology seems to get this to Hohenbuehelia cyphelliformis (I got the reference to the key via the ABFG forum). We have 3 records of Hohenbuehelia cyphelliformis and one of Hohenbuehelia petaloides in the local area.
Steve
May 24, 2015 at 9:24 am #34459Hello Steve I don’t find many of these and they don’t seem very easy. Looking through FAN3, they suggest
cyphelliformisis mainly on “woody herbs” and only rarely on branches of deciduous trees: cap is up to 9mm across. Then there is fluxiliswith 2-spored basidia (cap to 19mm). The other two possibilities are mastrucatawith a pale cap & very thick gelatinous layer and atrocaeruleawith dark brown to blackish cap and medium wide gelatinous layer. Cap size of these two is larger, up to 50 and 35mm respectively; but all the spore sizes seem very similar! May 24, 2015 at 8:26 pm #34460Hi, I have had another look at descriptions of H. cyphelliformis – in Funga Nordica and Buczacki, plus another run through Henrici’s key. It looks as though this has a smooth cap surface, though the distant gills fit. Also. The metuloids are thin-walled and easily missed – not as in my (sorry, Les’s) specimen. My problem is that I have only a single immature specimen!
Excluding larger species and those with more crowded gills leaves H. fluxilis – but that’s not right as the metuloids are scarce.
Which leaves a new British species – H. unguicularis – as a possibility. From the drawings in Funga Nordica the metuloids are a dead match. Plus the embedded metuloids are also a feature. “Cap surface white pruinose to tomentose, strigose towards attachment point; gills distant, relatively narrow; metuloids ± embedded in hymenium; pileipellis a trichoderm, with a tomentum of tufts, 45-210 µm high, of hyaline, smooth, thick-walled hyphae, and a repent layer of interwoven, thin- to thick-walled, brown incrusted hyphae.” However Henrici has the cap as almost black beneath the white pruina. Mine is grey – but immature.
Unfortunately FRDBI says this species is extinct and has only 5 records, two of which are doubtful.
😮 Henrici quotes that this species has been “very badly confused, fom the time of its description”.
I note that confusion has existed with Resupinatus has been a problem with this genus.
All in all looks like a very difficult genus as all species seem to be uncommon or rare (or to be more honest, rarely recorded and subject to detailed microscopy), so poorly worked out.
Steve
May 25, 2015 at 12:21 pm #34461Hello Steve I’ve had another breeze through my keys also! The Hohenbuehelia Section in FAN5 (1995) is by Steen Elborne – I don’t have FN.
According to his descriptions
fluxilis(as well as atrocaerulea & mastrucata) have “numerous metuloids on both edge and sides of lamellae…”. The metuloids of fluxilis & atrocaeruleamay be “…covered in thick conical cap of crystals…”. It says for mastrucata“…without or with very thin crystal cap…”. Out of these three, phaseoliform spores are only mentioned for atrocaerulea. I didn’t mention
unguicularisas this (and pinacearum) are separated in the key as having “…gills turning grey to black with age or on drying…”; indeed the description of unguicularissays “gills…pale brown to black”. I see Henrici says there are two recent collections from Kew and it is in the Checklist, so it could be this. I’d say
unguicularisor atrocaeruleafit best: the metuloids are up to 52µ in the former and 72µ in the later, so I’d probably go for atrocaeruleaalthough the gill spacing fits unguicularisbetter! May 25, 2015 at 1:05 pm #34462Hi Roy, Many thanks for your help with this one – much appreciated. It’s a real beauty microscopically. Just shows that the M in mycology stands for microscope.
As it’s now dried in an immature state then there’s no way we’ll know how the gills develop.
Oddly enough I had real problems identifying a Strobilurus from Longshaw – which also had very striking metuloids. The descriptions in the literature were very inconsistent. Even though it was under Pine I got it to be S. esculentus. However, we found plenty of it on Spruce last month so that gave us a more positive ID.
I’ll record this as H. cf. unguicularis on the basis of the metuloids as shown in Funga Nordica (available via Mykokey as well as in book form – just under £100 for the two volumes!).
Best wishes,
Steve
June 22, 2015 at 7:17 pm #34463I have recorded this species two years running on fallen Araucaria (Monkey Puzzle) branches from a very old tree. There is a very similar Crepidotus species but it is reported not have any cystidia. My specimens had typical Hohenbueheila cystidia, similar to those in your photos. I consulted Alick Henrici who confirmed my record. The spores of H. cyphelliformis are allantoid but I do not see any photos of these?
June 23, 2015 at 3:57 pm #34464I have located my photographs of H. cypelliformis. The spore is not so good but the shape is obvious. There are some very good photos on
http://www.asturnatura.com/fotografia-naturaleza/galeria.php?especie=hohenbuehelia-cyphelliformis ” class=”bbcode_url”> http://www.asturnatura.com/fotografia-naturaleza/galeria.php?especie=hohenbuehelia-cyphelliformis Note by Admin. Edited above text to correct non-working link.July 6, 2015 at 8:45 am #34465Hi, Unfortunately my specimen provided very few spores – I wouldn’t say they were particularly allantoid.
Steve
December 2, 2015 at 11:05 am #34466On 13th November, at Childwall Woods, Liverpool, found a similar fruitbody on a stick, probably lime (the area is subject to canine interference). I thought Crepidotus until I saw the cystidia, similar to yours. It looked at H. fluxilis but it had a 4 spored basidia. The only alternative I could find was H. mastrucata but it did not fit the descriptions. Kew showed interest so I sent it to them. Here is Martyn Ainsworth’s response.
‘The cap of typical mastrucata is highly distinctive with gelatinous projections and, as far as I can make out, you probably have something else. I don’t think further progress can easily be made with the microscope alone as I think there are several as yet undescribed species in this genus awaiting further sampling and sequencing work. So the choice is either to hang on to it or send it to us as Hohenbuehelia sp. with all your details and it will be put into the collections and made available to any of our and/or visiting researchers wishing to sequence/examine it. It could be in the atrocoerulea/grisea group but I think they need more work to work out exactly how many species occur in Europe before we can name all the unknowns. I’m sorry but in this case I think it unlikely that a swift determination can be provided.’
Not a lot of help I’m afraid. We now both have mysteries. Every sighting of Crepidotus will now be looked at most carefully.
December 4, 2015 at 4:25 pm #34467Another communication from Kew. Hope this helps. Following up on what I said about your Hohenbuehelia (see previous email, below), Alick Henrici kindly agreed to examine your specimen. He measured the spores as falling in the range 6-7 x 3-4, somewhat smaller than your size range.
Alick says that for him “this has to be atrocoerulea” and cited various notes from FAN3 and FN (both treatments by S. Elborne) that mastrucata is usally bigger, with thicker gelatinous layer and metuloids with little in the way of a crystal cap (whereas yours are heavily encrusted). I agree that your material and photo do not look like the mastrucata that I’ve seen. Alick, like me, is not completely happy with H. grisea as a distinct and recognisable taxon which is distinguished by Elborne. Again this is supposed to have thinly encrusted metuloid caps which doesn’t match your material (however the drawings of these cystidia in FN are unhelpful as encrustation not shown). So we agree that atrocoerulea is the best place to file it for now and I’ve done this as K(M) 200880.
I expect there are more species to be revealed within this genus and once the sequences have been published, we can revisit the issue of grisea/atrocoerulea and assign specimens accordingly.
December 7, 2015 at 1:21 pm #34468Moved to ID requests -
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.