Crustose on Salix, not Lecania

Forums › Forums › Lichens › Crustose on Salix, not Lecania

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #32798

    Hoping someone can help with the identity of these very small apothecia on a Salix twig in Dorset?

    Thallus K-, C-, UV+mauve, Asci 8-spored, spores initially appeared 0-1 septate but simple when stained with Melzers, 8-10(-12) x 4-5 µm, the paraphyses with slightly swollen dark tips.

    I’d initially wondered Lecania cyrtella from appearance but am now at a total loss!

    x1 Not Lecania 240402 008.jpg

    [attachment=7]x1 Not Lecania 240402 008.jpg[/attachment]

    x2 Not Lecania 240402 004.jpg

    [attachment=6]x2 Not Lecania 240402 004.jpg[/attachment]

    x3 NOT Lecania 240402-20.jpg

    [attachment=5]x3 NOT Lecania 240402-20.jpg[/attachment]

    x4 NOT Lecania 240402-20c.jpg

    [attachment=4]x4 NOT Lecania 240402-20c.jpg[/attachment]

    x5 Not Lecania 240402-4.jpg

    [attachment=3]x5 Not Lecania 240402-4.jpg[/attachment]

    x6 Not Lecania 240402-1.jpg

    [attachment=2]x6 Not Lecania 240402-1.jpg[/attachment]

    x7 Not Lecania 240402-8.jpg

    [attachment=1]x7 Not Lecania 240402-8.jpg[/attachment]

    x8 Not Lecania 240402-9b.jpg

    [attachment=0]x8 Not Lecania 240402-9b.jpg[/attachment]

    #46006
    Neil Sanderson
    Senior Moderator

      Jenny

      Possibly Japewiella tavaresiana? Seems to match quite well, except the spores are to small. There are a few records from Dorset and the habitat is OK

      Neil

      #46007

      Many thanks Neil – I had checked Japewiella tavaresiana as I’ve recorded it on Salix in Ireland but then discounted it because of the smaller spores in this specimen. Am I ok in recording it despite the spore size?

      Checked the BLS map and it shows a pre-2000 record of Japewiella tavaresiana in the neighbouring 10km square.

      #46008
      Neil Sanderson
      Senior Moderator

        Jenny

        Probably best not record it as that; the spore size is quite a bit out, but not sure what else it would be.

        Neil

        #46009
        Neil Sanderson
        Senior Moderator

          Although, looking at the pictures at https://fungi.myspecies.info/all-fungi/japewiella-tavaresiana” class=”bbcode_url”>https://fungi.myspecies.info/all-fungi/japewiella-tavaresiana, your matterial looks a very good match for Japewiella tavaresiana other than those spores.

          Neil

          #46010
          Mark Powell
          Participant

            There isn’t really a right or wrong answer as to whether this should be recorded as J. tavaresiana or not, it is perhaps more a matter of taxonomic judgement. People differ in their thresholds for recording a specimen as such and such. Looked at philosophically, the only specimens which are correctly named are the type specimens and the identification of every other specimen is a taxonomic judgement about whether the specimen in question is sufficiently similar to a type specimen to consider it the same taxon. Of course, we rarely have the opportunity to examine type material directly and have to use books or other resources as proxy. Some people are more inclined to want neat answers, to pigeon-hole each specimen they encounter, and then move on. Other people are more content to leave a proportion of specimens undetermined, awaiting further information.

            I will explain the approach I would take, without insisting that it is the only or best approach. If I had a specimen which I thought was close to J. tavaresiana but about which I had reservations, I would wait until I had the opportunity to examine a specimen of what seemed to be ‘good’ J. tavaresiana. Then I would mount sections of each, side by side, on a microscope slide, starting in water. Then I would add K, perhaps N, stain with e.g. ink-vinegar and also with iodine. There is nothing quite like examining two specimens side by side to get a feel for whether they seem to be the same taxon or not. This approach often reveals similarities or differences in pigment reactions, exciple structure and other characters which aren’t necessarily well-described in the literature.

            It was using this approach that I gradually convinced myself that Verrucaria ochrostoma was not just stunted V. viridula (which various lichenologists had suggested) and led me to help lift this species from Victorian obscurity, proving that it is not a rare species but is actually a common colonist, including of modern cement and concrete. Another little Verrucaria is remarkably common in churchyards, particularly in a niche well-loved by churchyard recorders, iron-stained limestone windowsills where a specialist community had been recognised for several decades. It is often dominant over large expanses of such limestone on church walls. I was unhappy to consider it as simply atypical V. nigrescens, modified by the the metal run-off and it was by making many side by side sections that I noted significant and consistent differences. I added this little Verrucaria on iron-stained limestone to the British list in 2015 as V. obfuscans. Many other examples spring to mind in which I made progress by this side by side approach.

            #46011

            Thanks Neil and Mark – even though it does seem a likely match for Japewiella tavaresiana apart from spore size (possibly immature specimen, spores released early when squashed?) as that would be a good record for Dorset I’d rather not record it unless certain.

            Its possible I might have a bit of Japewiella tavaresiana among my Irish specimens and if so I’ll try comparing the two

            #46012

            Can I just throw Lecidea erythrophaea into the mix. I think of that species as resembling Catillaria (lax paraphyses with a distiinct pigmented cap) but with a different ascus structure, and that fits the photos of this collection. The ascus appears to be Bacidia-type (penultimate photo), which is the same as erythrophaea but not J. tavaresiana (Lecidella-type). We still have the small spore problem ((8–) 9–14 (–18) × 3–4.5 (–5) µm in L. erythrophaea) but at least the spore width fits.

            Alan

            #46013

            Thank you Alan – that’s a very interesting possibility, and spore size would fit though mine are on the short side and therefore wider in proportion to length as the spores in my specimen were (8-)10-12 x 4-5 µm.

            #46014

            Hi Jenny:

            I didn’t want to say too much in my previous post because I wanted to check some collections. We have an undescribed species from southern Sweden that is close to L. erythrophaea but has smaller spores (10–12 × 4–5 µm), which is more or less the same as those of your collection. The Swedish collections are all on Fraxinus and the young apothecia have a distinct proper margin so I can’t say for certain that your collection is that species, but it certainly appears to be close.

            Please hang on to your collection because we may want to sequence it – and if you can find more, that would be even better.

            Alan

            #46015

            Many thanks for your further comment Alan – Lecidea erythrophaea would be new to Dorset but your so far undescribed species would be an even more interesting find!

            I’ve retained the rest of the specimen but could I post it to you for safer keeping in case I can’t find more?

            Jenny

            #46016

            Jenny: I’ll message you – Alan

          Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
          • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
          Scroll to Top