Cladonia chlorophaea agg. ?

Forums › Forums › Lichens › Cladonia chlorophaea agg. ?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #31999

    Mark Powell suggested I post this one on here for potential clarification by Neil. I’m thinking Cladonia chlorophaea agg. based on C- K-, No UV reaction on medulla, coarsely sorediate on podetia and inside cups. Primary thallus grey-green with no soredia, white underneath & slightly indented. Rotting fence post habitat along with moss. I know most peoples view is to run away from a firm ID on Cladonia’s, but this one seemed pretty certain unless I have a variety of C. fimbriata (but too coarse soredia I think).

    2021-01-22-16-25-55-(B,Radius6,Smoothing1).jpg

    [attachment=4]2021-01-22-16-25-55-(B,Radius6,Smoothing1).jpg[/attachment]

    2021-01-22-17-16-37-(A,Radius4,Smoothing1).jpg

    [attachment=3]2021-01-22-17-16-37-(A,Radius4,Smoothing1).jpg[/attachment]

    2021-01-22-17-22-42-(B,Radius4,Smoothing1).jpg

    [attachment=2]2021-01-22-17-22-42-(B,Radius4,Smoothing1).jpg[/attachment]

    IMG_20210122_100841943_HDR.jpg

    [attachment=1]IMG_20210122_100841943_HDR.jpg[/attachment]

    IMG_20210122_100747654_HDR.jpg

    [attachment=0]IMG_20210122_100747654_HDR.jpg[/attachment]

    #43928
    Neil Sanderson
    Senior Moderator

      Mark

      Great some Cladonia pictures. Yes Cladonia chlorophaea s. lat. is a safe ID for this but does not help much as the name as used currently in Britain covers two groups of genetically unrelated pixie cups: the course sorediata members of the Cladonia pyxidata group (the group includes Cladonia pyxidata, Cladonia pocillum, Cladonia chlorophaea s. str. and Cladonia fimbriata) and the Cladonia grayi group (Cladonia grayi, Cladonia cryptochlorophaea, Cladonia merochlorophaea and Cladonia novochlorophaea plus). The latter are typically found in strongly acid habitats, often have brownish cortex colours present, the medula is often pinkish brown tinged, sometimes darker, and often have some other positive spot tests beyond the ubiquitous Pd + brick red spot test (fumarprotocetraric acid) or have UV fluorescence. The taxonomy is not yet fixed but it looks like the segregates are probably good species. Nearly every pixie cup in acid heath habitats is a member of the Cladonia grayi group, the problem is which one.

      The sorediate members of the Cladonia pyxidata group (Cladonia chlorophaea s. str. and Cladonia fimbriata) have an entirely green coloured cortex, a mainly white medulla and no spot tests beyond the the ubiquitous Pd + brick red and no UV fluorescence. In contrast to the Cladonia grayi group to date the evidence suggests that Cladonia pyxidata, Cladonia pocillum and Cladonia chlorophaea s. str. at least are not genetically separate species but are habitat morphs of Cladonia pyxidata. No sure about Cladonia fimbriata, no one seems to have looked at this much. Cladonia chlorophaea s. str. is not found on the most acid soils/lignum and is more typical of acid grasslands, loamy banks and less acid lignum.

      Now for you specimen. Not too easy to say without it in hand (and even then with pixie cups, without TLC the determination would just be an opinion) but it looks most likely to be Cladonia chlorophaea s. str.: no brown colours in the cortex, no additional spot tests or UV and a nutrient rich environment but the medula is brownish however. Definitely not Cladonia fimbriata, as you say, too coarsely sorediate.

      NB please test potential Cladonia fimbriata with KC: a lot of what I use to record as Cladonia fimbriata on acid trees has proved to be gracile Cladonia cryptochlorophaea. This has the same elegant golf tee shape potedia but is a bit more coarsely sorediate and is KC + purple (fleeting).

      Warning identifying Cladonia leads to madness

      Neil

      #43929

      Hi Neil

      Thanks very much for this amazing amount of detail and I really appreciate the time taken to reply. Provisional Cladonia chlorophaea s. str. ID noted as is the test for fimbriata. First signs of madness detected :)

      All the best

      Mark

    Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
    • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
    Scroll to Top